The Cays

A cluster of tiny inhabited and private cays off Utila's southwest tip, offering rare island-within-an-island ownership.

Updated June 17, 202611 min read

About The Cays

The Utila Cays are a string of small islands off the southwest tip of Utila, including the densely settled fishing community of Jewel Cay and Pigeon Cay (linked by a causeway) plus privately held cays like Water Cay and Sandy Cay. They offer one of the Caribbean's rarest propositions: ownership of, or on, a private or semi-private cay, attracting trophy buyers and boutique-rental operators. Inventory is scarce and pricing varies enormously: a modest cay home may trade from US$150,000 to US$400,000, while entire small private cays command seven figures. Rental potential is strong for unique day-trip and overnight stays but logistically dependent on boat access. This is the island's most illiquid, specialized segment, rewarding buyers seeking a trophy asset or distinctive boutique-rental over conventional cash flow; corporate title is standard for these coastal holdings.

Location

The Cays in Utila, Islas de la Bahía, Honduras

Showing this map loads it from Google Maps, which sets their own cookies on your device.

Unlock the full neighbourhood guide. It's free.

You've read the preview. 4 more sections are open to Explorer members, instantly, with just an email.

No spam, no password, unsubscribe any time.

Already a member? Sign in

  • Lifestyle scores
  • Amenities and places
  • Community
  • Investment and pricing

Figures are indicative and subject to change. Regulations, taxes and market conditions vary by jurisdiction. Do your own due diligence and seek independent legal and financial advice.

More in Utila

All neighbourhoods